Welcome to another brutally honest review of the wines in the 2026 Costco Wine Advent-ure Calendar!

In case you’re just joining us, we’re tasting all 24 wines in the Costco box. We’ve split them up into four batches of six. The least-bad wine in each grouping wins a prize: the honor of being paired with dinner, rather than being dumped down the drain.

Missed our first installment of 2026 advent calendar reviews? See how wines #1-6 fared here.

Wines #7-12 are waiting on the counter. They include what looks like a perfectly normal French Cabernet and a California Chardonnay…plus a couple of weirder bottles, including a pistachio-chocolate flavored red wine.

I’ll admit I’m a little bit afraid of what’s lurking under those festive red and gold foils. But I’ve already committed to this project–and there’s no way through it but to do it. Bottoms up!


Costco 2026 Wine Advent-ure Calendar reviews: Wines #7-12

Entering the ring is “Right Hook,” a ripasso-style red wine from southern Italy:

Wine #7: Right Hook Ripasso (2024) – Puglia, Italy

“‘Ripasso’ here refers to a richer, more concentrated winemaking style where red grapes are re-fermented on skins. Unlike Valpolicella Ripasso, this wine from Puglia doesn’t identify its grape varieties.

“Right Hook” has a tart, boozy nose of soured red wine, blackberry, and cinnamon. Firm, drying tannins with just a touch of sweetness and a metallic aftertaste.

It smells both sour and overripe at the same time. It tastes like a cupful of fruit juice and pennies. I put it next to my plant and it killed my plant. (Okay–just kidding about the plant. But it’s not recommended that you drink this.) Grade: D


Wine #8: Racer 67 Pistachio Chocolate Grape Wine with Natural Flavors and Artificial Colors (NV) – France

A medium brick-red color with aromas of peanut-butter sandwich cookie, vanilla-scented candle, almond praline, and milk-chocolate covered raisins.

The palate is sweet, but not sticky-sweet. Flavors of jammy raspberry and cherry fade away, leaving some leafy raspberry herb tea. The promised “natural flavors” re-emerge, offering a nutty finish of almonds and graham crackers and a dry-cocoa aftertaste. This may be faint praise…but I’d venture to say “Racer 67” is better than the chocolate wine in last year’s Costco wine calendar.

It’s still strange and artificial. The label describes it as an “unforgettable treat”–but after the obligatory two sips, I’m doing my best to forget it. Grade: D+


Wine #9: Who’s Who Riesling (2025) – Landwein Rhein, Germany

Pale lemon color with fine dissolved bubbles. Aromas of hard green orchard fruit, unripe peaches, citrus blossom, and lemon. It’s off-dry with high acid and faint flavors of canned pear and white flowers. A modest, lightly effervescent finish with citrus and fresh ginger.

Honestly, I don’t taste much here besides sweetness and acidity–like putting a drop of lemon juice on a sugar cube–but at least those elements are in balance. Later, I poured this Riesling over crushed ice, and I eventually stopped noticing the lack of flavor. Grade: C+


Wine #10: Les Champs d’Or Cabernet Sauvignon (2025) – Pays d’Oc, France

Blackberry, vanilla oak, spices, medium acid and tannin. It’s not good. But it’s better than the Apothic Cab that I had at a house party last week, so there’s that. Grade: C–


Wine #11: Maison du Lac Sauvignon Blanc (2025) – France

Eagle eyes may notice that last year’s “Maison du Lac” was labeled as a white Bordeaux, while this year’s carries the broader national appellation. A mere Vin de France, Costco? How gauche. But whatever–it’s Sauvy B and it’s cold. Cheers!

Like many of the white wines in this year’s calendar, “Maison du Lac” appears to be bottled with dissolved CO₂ that gives it a slight fizz upon pouring. Pear, pineapple, and citrus with lackluster acidity and little flavor intensity. Drinkable, but not memorable. A typical “Sauvignon blank.” Grade: C


Wine #12: North Thirty-Eight Chardonnay – California

Sour green apple and popcorn butter, with orange-juice aromas emerging as it warms in the glass. Watery tasting and presence-less, aside from some moderate palate density from alcohol. The worst white wine in the 2026 calendar so far. Grade: D


The second-round winner is…

After the disappointing performance of the first half-dozen wines, I was really rooting for this batch of six to swoop in and serve up some redemption. But once again, there’s very little here to justify the Costco box and its $100 price tag.

So, which bottle of wine are we taking to the table?

The actual highest-scoring wine in Group 2 was the “Who’s Who” Riesling. It was fruity and easy to swallow. But alas–it didn’t make it all the way to dinnertime. (It was probably too underpowered to pair with food, anyway.) I drank that 9% ABV guzzler after work, in the tub with candles and bubble bath, like a proper suburban wino.

The second highest-scoring wine was the “Maison du Lac,” but it was summarily disqualified because we chose a Sauvignon Blanc last week.

And, so the winner by default is:

🌟 #10: Les Champs d’Or Cabernet Sauvignon

This bland-but-functional Pays d’Oc Cabernet is both red and liquid. It reminds me of the house wines in Europe that cost less than a soft drink. That’s wine that you drink with a smile–not because it’s great, but because it’s €3 and you’re on vacation.

So that is my prescription for optimizing subpar advent-calendar wine: Plate up something delicious, pull out the crappiest stemware you own, and pretend like you’re enjoying a slow dinner at a cozy French bistro.

I paired this budget Cab with braised short ribs, Swiss chard, and roasted campari tomatoes over soft polenta.

Review disclosure: I was not compensated or provided any free products for this review. Opinions expressed on The Wine Fairy blog are entirely my own.

How I review and score wines

Leave a Comment


Subscribe to New Posts


The Wine Fairy on Instagram (@winefairymichelle)